We've all heard the phrase "You can't go wrong, it's a classic!"
It's normally uttered by someone over the age of 50 and a grandfather desperately clinging to the glory days of his past. This is their way of paying respect to the time when they were on the cusp of manhood discovering their own generational style. Back then, a cab meant a horse and carriage, TV didn't have TIVO and polyester was a natural organic fabric.
But what does it mean? What makes a piece of clothing or accessory a classic? Why is the bomber jacket, the Gucci loafer and a navy blue suit a classic?
Tailcoats were once a classic, but they're not any more. They're old fashioned only worn by butlers, gay chorus boys on Broadway wearing leggings and occasional crazy drunks named Arthur who are funny as hell. High-heeled pumps and powdered wigs were all the rage for the founding fathers, but in today's society it's a bit RuPaul's Drag Race versus something acceptable you can wear to a board meeting. So how does something become a classic?
After spending a lot of time researching, which includes interviewing my personal shopper at Barney's who thinks classic pieces means paying full retail for things that will one day be classics on the planet Tron and looking at all the men's fashion magazines--who are quick to call everything and their mother a classic--I realized that what is defined as a classic isn't well defined, like that one time at band camp or that camping trip with the Boy Scouts. Pitching a tent among other guys is apparently natural. It's a gray area.
What was considered a classic in the 70's meant a boxy suit but made in polyester with a Tombstone moustache. The classic silhouette of the 80's referenced the power suits of the 1950's drag net but included a mullet and pleated/tapered pants that ushered in MC Hammer in the 90's. Neither is a good example of classic long standing style. I think of the term classic as an antiquated trend that is only remembered by the men who are still alive long enough to remember and convince the rest of us that it's a classic. The tie, coat and dress shirt have been around for hundreds of years but they evolve and change. And hats come and go depending on which celebrity is sporting his inner trucker until he unleashes a cowboy at heart.
Today's classic is tomorrow's old-fashioned.
Therefore, a classic men's piece is something that your grandfather owned that you want to cling to. My grandfather loved Cuban cigars, Gucci loafers and manicures. He passed this on to my dad who's passed it on to me. That's what makes it a classic for me and why it works with my wardrobe. It connects me to my past even though it's not directly passed on to me from my past. I'm not wearing my grandad's loafers, but when I bought my first pair, he's the guy I was thinking of as I charged it to Amex. So go ahead and identify your own classics and charge forward.
YES: A classic is what you make of it. But jewelry is a good start.
NO: It's not a classic just because you saw it in a Ralph Lauren catalog or a sales person at Brooks Brothers said it's a classic. Remember, it's their job to sell you stuff.
MAYBE: You can start your own classic tradition. I'm working to make wood prayer bracelets stick. I'm not even Buddhist.